Archive for October, 2009
Bulb Coralife
Tuesday, October 27th, 2009
Uv Sterilization in Aquariums; Misinformation
I continue to follow the threads on forums, aquarium articles, and blogs about UV Sterilization. It still amazes me much misinformation spread about this, some masked in science. As I have stated many times before, a UV Sterilizer is not essential for any aquarium, however even for goldfish I have had maintained tanks with as many variables (similarities) in place as possible and noted the differences and this includes thriving reef tanks.
What I also find interesting is that many of these same persons who trash them will then state a Protein Skimmer as essential. I have maintained tanks with and without Skimmers (again every other possible variable the same or as close as possible), and noted the changes in measurable parameters and found that yes they are useful, however often not by much and that Mud Filters, DIY DSB filters or similar can often replace them (as well as UV Sterilizers and good over head lighting such as MH).
Back to the subject at hand, here is a thread I will comment on. In this thread one person who offered proof (albeit not of the perfect scientific nature, but as good as it can often be within this hobby) was attacked dog pile style without other backing up their statements other than criticizing his methods:
Arthur #1 (Edited):
“If you read some scientific documents about UV sterilization of water you will know they talk usually about a standard long, 40W mercury UV tube in a 3″ diameter lamp and water passing at the speed about 500 gph or less. This kind of setup delivers dosage of about 18,000 mW-sec/cm2. In order to increase this dosage you need to lower the water flow. For example, 250 gph
flow will in above mentioned lamp would be exposed to the almost double dosage of 34,000 mW-sec/cm2. This dosage is enough to kill bacteria, yeast, some mold spores, viruses and microalgae. And some aquarium grade lamps achive this effect with unicellular algea. To kill protozoa (like a well known from school “Paramecium” or our ich-causing “Cryptocaryon irritans”)
you would have to increase the dosage.
MY COMMENT:
First, most studies I have read show under 10,000 mW per se/cm2 for bacteria. Second, I have read articles that have shown 30,000 + mW-sec/cm2 with 90 watt bulbs at a rate of 200 + gallons per MINUTE (which even I find hard to believe, my point often it depends on whose data you look at. Third, there is more to treatment of Cryptocaryon than just out right sterilization (I would not want it that high in my reef tanks!!!), there is also the Redox potential which Sterilizers improve and also general water quality.
Finally each unit is different and there are many variables from age of the bulb (even a 3 month old bulb has lost 25%), to temperature, design of the unit, pre filtration (a micron pre filter vastly improves sterilization), and to flow rate which I have found to be best at 20 gph (or less for most good units in aquarium applications).
Arthur #2 (edited):
Without a hospital tank, adding a new fish was always hazardous. Back when I had
no UV on the tank, once one of the fish started showing signs, the life
expectancy of that fish was usually less than 3 days; they could not take the
combined stress of the parasites and the copper treatment. Other fish in the
tank would invariably show signs of infestation later, but would usually make it
through. Once the first sterilizer was added, the rate at which the disease
spread decreased; my theory is that some of the parasites were being killed in
their free-swimming stage. After that, the first fish to show signs usually
survived, and some of the other fish would never show any signs at all.
Once I added the second sterilizer, I never lost a fish to ich, though I did get
the occasional infestation. In short, there was a direct relationship to the
number of watts of UV and the intensity and rate of spread of the disease.
Since I was not religious in changing the bulbs (and the bulbs get less
effective with time), I was also in a position to notice that an outbreak was
worse when the sterilizer bulb was pretty old. Again, this didn’t happen once I
had two units running.
MY COMMENT:
This person most likely had decent units with low flow rates, pre filtration, and useful discernment.
Without elaborating too much (my expanded articles have much about this), as stated earlier there are other aspects of UV Sterilizers such Redox Potential, this is not a hard test to perform; simply test the Redox without a UV and then run one for a week and test again, easy! So many person who trash persons like this have not considered all the variables if they have failed, myself I have seen UV Sterilizers not do a damn thing. These were often 8 watt Units running off a sump with a flow rate of 800 gph, a calcified quartz sleeve and poor pre filtration. This is not to say a 8 watt unit (or less) cannot work, just not under those conditions (and in the case a brand I will not mention, a poor mixing chamber design as well). The 15 Watt Custom UV Sterilizer I made has performed well in most every application I have placed it in (The Terminator Compact UV Sterilizers do well too, one of the best compact UVs I have used along with the ReSun and Coralife).
What a UV Sterilizer is, is a tool for good aquarium husbandry along with water changes, filtration, Protein Skimmers and more. In many of my side by side applications with and without, the UV was just one more piece of the puzzle to improved water quality in let’s face it, an artificial environment (unless we want to kid ourselves). I can think of one experiment in particular with several goldfish tanks at a large service customer of mine. All these tanks in particular had canister filters, cleaning and the same feeding schedule and bio load; the only difference was UV Sterilizers. The difference in amount of diseased goldfish, growth and color was very noticeable (the vice president did not no we were performing this experiment and even commented about why some tanks did better than others, after which she had us install UV Sterilizers on all).
For my FULL aricle (including references and more links), please visit this site:
Aquarium and Pond UV Sterilizer
About the Author
By Carl Strohmeyer
Fluval Edge Marine setup coralife bulb LEDs coming
|
|
Purely Products PUVH2309 9-Watt UV-C Germicidal Ultraviolet Replacement Bulb $9.15 Purely UV-C Replacement Bulbs G23 BasePurely UV-C Replacement bulbs offer a much higher concentration of ultraviolet light than even the sun, making them highly effective as a cleaning and purifying agent for pond and aquarium pumps and clarifiers.What is UV and How Does it Work?UV light is germicidal – i.e., it deactivates the DNA of bacteria, viruses and other pathogens and thus destroys their a… |
|
|
Aqueon Coralife 05481 50/50 Square Pin Compact Fluorescent Lamp, 28-Watt $14.99 50 percent natural daylight 6000K, 50 percent actinic 03 blue. Ideal for saltwater, reef and freshwater aquariums. Provides required light for essential biological reactions. Enhances color and clarity. Full-spectrum. High-intensity output. Rugged contruction for dependable long life. Easy to install. Energy-efficient. Japanese square pin arrangement. Confused about Compact Fluorescent Pin … |
|
|
15W 20000 K Fluorescent Bulb 18 $17.55 The Coralife 20,000 Kelvin fluorescent lamp is a high-intensity purified super-daylight lamp that is ideal for deeper aquariums. It casts a bright, blue-white glow allowing light to penetrate deeper into the aquarium. Also available with a 180o highly-pol… |
|
|
39watt Coral Sun T5 Ho Flo Bulb 34 (Catalog Category: Aquarium / Florescent Bulbs) $23.29 39watt Coral Sun T5 Ho Flo Bulb 34. Zoo Med Labs – Coral Sun T5 HO Lamp 34 39WActinic 420, Combine with Zoo Meds Ocean Sun for a more subdued deepwater tank effect Combine with Zoo Meds Ultra Sun for optimum viewing pleasure of live fish and corals… |
|
|
Ballast For Aqualight Pro Hqi 250w (Catalog Category: Aquarium / Lighting Kits Parts) $378.43 Ballast For Aqualight Pro Hqi 250w. Coralife – BALLAST HQI AQLIGHT PRO 250Replacement Aqualight Ballast for one 250 watt MH lamps Works with Aqualight PRO 250 and 250 watt pendant… |
|
|
Ballast For Aqualight Pro Hqi 150w (Catalog Category: Aquarium / Lighting Kits Parts) $364.39 Ballast For Aqualight Pro Hqi 150w. Coralife – BALLAST HQI AQLIGHT PRO 150150 watt metal halide ballast for use with Aqualight Pro and Aqualight Advanced fixtures… |
|
|
Loving Pets Gourmet Treats Duck 8 oz $7.49 “These Gourmet Meat Strips are 100% all natural Duck.Glucosamine and Chondroiton are added for joint health,but no fillers or preservatives are. “6 oz… |
|
|
48 Nova Extreme Pro 6x54w Slimpaq T5ho 10k/460nm (Catalog Category: Aquarium / Lighting Kits Parts) $1,436.52 48 Nova Extreme Pro 6x54w Slimpaq T5ho 10k/460nm. Current USA – Nova Extreme Pro T5 High Output Lighting FixtureIndividually contoured reflectors for maximum light intensityCool running, performancedriven electronic ballastFancooled for superior color spectrum, output and lifespaThe Nova Extreme Pro combines the best in both design and functionality, making it a great addition to any aquarium The… |
|
|
PL-S 9W/TUV PHILLIPS STERILAMP GERMICIDAL STERILIZER BULB $17.95 PL-S9W/TUV This germicidal is a 9 watt Phillips Sterilamp G23 pin base length 6.6 inches useful Rated life 8000 hours This type of bulb should only be used in a fixture made for UV light. Replacement bulb for UV Sterilizers Cyprio, Oase, Bitron, CustomSeaLife, Vortron, Coralife NAIL SALON EQUIPMENT AND AIR CLEANERS UV light can be dangerous. Please use care!… |
|
|
Pilgrimage to the West (Definitive Edition) (Chinese Edition) $12.99 When you need the ultimate in lighting for your aquarium, nothing illuminates like metal halide. This spectacularly bright bulb mimics the high-intensity light of the midday sun while producing the same refracted shimmering, dappled look of natural sunlight. With the highest light-output-per-watt you can find, this double-ended halide lamp brings out vibrant colors and keeps your corals, plants, o… |
